Entering the 1999-2000 season:
| Team | Total |
| 1. Washington U. (24) | 624 |
| 2. St. Benedict | 575 |
| 3. Capital (1) | 530 |
| 4. Scranton | 511 |
| 5. UW-Oshkosh | 417 |
| 6. Salem State | 408 |
| 7. Gallaudet | 332 |
| 8. Pacific Lutheran | 294 |
| 9. Johns Hopkins | 274 |
| T10. NYU | 250 |
| T10. Cortland State | 250 |
| 12. Baldwin-Wallace | 243 |
| 13. Rowan | 237 |
| 14. Ohio Wesleyan | 210 |
| 15. Williams | 207 |
| 16. William Smith | 205 |
| 17. Calvin | 199 |
| 18. Gwynedd-Mercy | 188 |
| 19. TCNJ | 185 |
| 20. St. Lawrence | 184 |
| 21. Simpson | 183 |
| 22. Millikin | 153 |
| 23. St. Thomas | 151 |
| 24. UW-Eau Claire | 148 |
| 25. Bowdoin | 142 |
Others receiving votes: Hardin-Simmons 138; DePauw 120; Southern Maine 111; Elizabethtown 111; Randolph-Macon 81; Springfield 76; St. Mary's (Md.) 63; Colby-Sawyer 42; Hope 41; Wilmington 31; Defiance 28; Bates 24; Lake Forest 24; Elmira 21; Mount Union 15; Hendrix 12; Marymount 11; UC San Diego 9; Wheaton (Ill.) 9; Hartwick 9; Bridgewater (Va.) 9; Franklin 8; William Paterson 6; RPI 6; Wartburg 5; Mississippi College 4; UW-Whitewater 4; Gustavus Adolphus 2; Illinois Wesleyan 2; Lakeland 2; Emory 1.
The D3hoops.com Top 25 is voted on by a panel of 25 coaches, Sports Information Directors and media members from across the country, and is published weekly.